Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

[bdbl]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

That could be considered advice:
2 stroke penalty, or
loss of hole in match play.

Not sure about that.

Pointing out OB would be factual so I'd have thought been in the rules and "same as last time" could be construed as encouragement not advice - if I was potentially on the receiving end of 2 stroke penalty I'd certainly argue the case

[LowPost42]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

Not sure about that.

Pointing out OB would be factual so I'd have thought been in the rules and "same as last time" could be construed as encouragement not advice - if I was potentially on the receiving end of 2 stroke penalty I'd certainly argue the case

Advice is not implied about anything otherwise known - such as hazards, course conditions, etc.

However, this makes me wonder if it's OK to ask about your yardage - would it be considered 'otherwise known', especially if the sprinklerheads are marked?

[Started2k3]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

My point was to try to come up with a way to shut the guy up.

"same as last time" because it is telling Greg how to do the next shot, while Greg hase many more options than the "shape" of the last shot. Hence, advice.

Stating where OB is located (right) is in a sense telling Greg where to aim (left) ... advice.

[golfseeker]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

It seems to me any advice is bad advice. What creeps into your thoughts (almost automatically) puts you in the mechanical mode of thinking. That is the worst thing that can happen while playing. I never, ever, say anything to my playing buddies.....unless they ask me for my advice.

[Leverpowergolfer]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

Is advice based on opinions or assumptions. I will take advice based on true scientific facts.

[SuperGolferMan]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

My Uncle and my dad got clubs from my Gramps when they were little. My dad kept the clubs and loved it his whole life and then started me while my uncle sold his clubs as soon as he got them, HAH!

So...My uncle said if somebody gives you clubs, sell them and don't waste your time with it! Terrible advice!

[jbrunk]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

Keep you head still.......................

[Neil18]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

My two favourites:

Hit down on the ball

Keep your head down

[Mox]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

Swing harder!

[Neil18]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

Other bad swing advice:

Kneel down at address

Roll a cigarette during your downswing

Oil your hands before playing

Play every shot towards Mecca (either in the middle east, or the bingo hall)

[BrianW]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

I don't think raise your head when swinging would be very good advice?

Your bum looks big in those trousers is no go advice for my wife

Burnt Ochre trousers and Powder Blue shirt "Suit you Sir" from the pro shop assistant would not rate to highly with me.

"I cant understand why you hit that bad shot" type advice does not really motivate me.

"If you would not have <enter the error here> then you would have putted that one" also does not float my boat.

[Neil18]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

I don't think raise your head when swinging would be very good advice?

I presume you refer to "keep your head down"?

Saying "keep your head down" is bad advice is not the same as saying "raise your head"!

Keep your chin up/keep your height/look down your nose at the ball, is more what I'd say.

I think "Keep your head down" is responsible for poor posture changes during the swing, conjures images of people burying their chin into their chest and fatting and thinning followed swiftly by chucking and swearing!

[BrianW]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

I presume you refer to "keep your head down"?

Saying "keep your head down" is bad advice is not the same as saying "raise your head"!

Keep your chin up/keep your height/look down your nose at the ball, is more what I'd say.

I think "Keep your head down" is responsible for poor posture changes during the swing, conjures images of people burying their chin into their chest and fatting and thinning followed swiftly by chucking and swearing!

Sure Neil, I understand.

I like to think about keeping the head stable with no bobbing.

[Neil18]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

Sure Neil, I understand.

I like to think about keeping the head stable with no bobbing.

Another good one!

[BrianW]

Re: Worse Golf Advise You've Gotten

Another good one!

OK, whats wrong with that